Skip to main content

How does the principle of free speech, as opposed to freedom of religion, apply to this case?

In spite of the fact that this case was triggered by Jehovah's Witnesses students arguing that they should not be forced to salute the flag or recite the Pledge of Allegiance, there is no freedom of religion argument to be made.  At least in theory, a group of atheists could have brought this case. The argument is that the freedom of speech includes the freedom to not speak, to not be compelled to profess a...

In spite of the fact that this case was triggered by Jehovah's Witnesses students arguing that they should not be forced to salute the flag or recite the Pledge of Allegiance, there is no freedom of religion argument to be made.  At least in theory, a group of atheists could have brought this case. The argument is that the freedom of speech includes the freedom to not speak, to not be compelled to profess a belief, in this case, to not recite the Pledge of Allegiance, and to not salute, since hand gestures are considered a form of speech.  People should not be compelled to pledge allegiance to their country if they choose not to do so.


I would guess there are those who would argue that this case somehow is of use to argue that religious beliefs should be protected to the degree that marriage license clerks should have the right to decline to issue marriage licenses, but the case is of no use as support for such arguments, for any number of reasons, but in particular because it has nothing to do with religion.  Supreme Court Justices usually try to rule on grounds as narrow as possible, so cases cannot be misused later on to make bad law.  

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

What is the meaning of "juggling fiends" in Macbeth?

Macbeth is beginning to realize that the three witches have been deceiving him since he first encountered them. Like jugglers, they have kept changing their forecasts in order create confusion. This is particularly apparent when the Second Apparition they raise in Act IV,   Scene 1 tells him that no man of woman born can overcome him in hand-to-hand battle--and then Macbeth finds himself confronted by the one man he has been avoiding out of a... Macbeth is beginning to realize that the three witches have been deceiving him since he first encountered them. Like jugglers, they have kept changing their forecasts in order create confusion. This is particularly apparent when the Second Apparition they raise in Act IV,   Scene 1 tells him that no man of woman born can overcome him in hand-to-hand battle--and then Macbeth finds himself confronted by the one man he has been avoiding out of a sense of guilt, and that man tells him: Despair thy charm. And let the angel whom thou still hast serve...
Post a Comment
Read more

Discuss movements that were inspired by the Civil Rights Movement and list one success for each group.

African-Americans contributed in a very big way during World War II. These contributions were demonstrated at home and on the battlefield. After the war, African-Americans properly felt it was time for them to achieve equality with white Americans. During the 1950's, the modern Civil Rights Movement was born and it had a number of successes (integration of the military and Brown vs. Board of Education as examples.) This success inspired other activists to demand change... African-Americans contributed in a very big way during World War II. These contributions were demonstrated at home and on the battlefield. After the war, African-Americans properly felt it was time for them to achieve equality with white Americans. During the 1950's, the modern Civil Rights Movement was born and it had a number of successes (integration of the military and Brown vs. Board of Education as examples.) This success inspired other activists to demand change for their agendas. Two examples of moveme...
Post a Comment
Read more

In Martel's Life of Pi, how does writing a diary help Pi Patel build on his leadership skills?

At the end of chapter 73, Pi first divulges the fact that he had started a diary after about a week alone at sea. Pi claims that he wrote about "practical stuff" (208) such as what he caught for food, foreseeable problems and solutions, Richard Parker, and reflections about specific events that occurred. In a sense, Pi is the captain of his ship; therefore, he must take responsibility for himself and his crew. He can... At the end of chapter 73, Pi first divulges the fact that he had started a diary after about a week alone at sea. Pi claims that he wrote about "practical stuff" (208) such as what he caught for food, foreseeable problems and solutions, Richard Parker, and reflections about specific events that occurred. In a sense, Pi is the captain of his ship; therefore, he must take responsibility for himself and his crew. He can do this by writing down events, problems and solutions, and reflections to look back on when confronted with repeated problems. It can ...
Post a Comment
Read more