Skip to main content

During their first meeting, which statement about the young woman's life provides Holmes with a good clue?

There are several points during Miss Stoner's introduction to her case that we might see as clues for Mr. Holmes. I'll list them off and you can choose which you think was most influential to the investigation.


First, Miss Stoner tells us that her stepfather is the last surviving member of one of the oldest and wealthiest families of England. Due to poor management of affairs, his family's fortune has been wasted over the past...

There are several points during Miss Stoner's introduction to her case that we might see as clues for Mr. Holmes. I'll list them off and you can choose which you think was most influential to the investigation.


First, Miss Stoner tells us that her stepfather is the last surviving member of one of the oldest and wealthiest families of England. Due to poor management of affairs, his family's fortune has been wasted over the past century. When Dr. Roylott married Miss Stoner's mother, he gained access to her wealth. Because her income was by inheritance of her family's wealth, Dr. Roylott would really only have control over the money in the event of her death. Helen mentions that her mother died under mysterious circumstances several years prior, and the money she left behind supported Helen, her sister, and their stepfather. In fact, they were so well off that Dr. Roylott stopped trying to set up a business in London and moved the family out to his country estate. 


From these statements, we might infer that Dr. Roylott married Helen's mother for her money. We come to assume that he was responsible for the mother's death, but even if he was not, he had much to gain from her death. Having used up all of the money his wife left behind-- save Helen and Julia's inheritance-- he might have been driven to kill the daughters in an effort to have access to their money.


Next, there is the mention that Dr. Roylott keeps many exotic pets. This might have tipped off Holmes as to the means of murder.


Finally, when Helen comes to describe her present circumstances of her recent engagement to be married and hearing whistling in the night, Holmes calls particular attention to her stepfather. He finds it suspicious that she would leave mention of him out of her story, especially as they live in the same house. Holmes discerns that he was quite angry with her, most likely about the engagement, as she has a bruised hand-print on her wrist. I think that if anything were to point Holmes' suspicions towards Dr. Roylott, it would be the fact that Julia Stoner died after becoming engaged, and now that Helen is engaged she fears for her life. 

Popular posts from this blog

In chapter one of The Great Gatsby, what advice does Nick's father give him? How does this make him a good person to tell this story?

Nick says that his father advised him that, before "criticizing anyone," he "remember that all the people in this world haven't had the same advantages" as Nick.  As a result, Nick claims that he is "inclined to reserve all judgments," presenting himself to the reader as a fair and dispassionate arbiter of character, and thus, a reliable narrator.   The problem is that Nick immediately reveals himself as anything but reliable, as he then launches... Nick says that his father advised him that, before "criticizing anyone," he "remember that all the people in this world haven't had the same advantages" as Nick.  As a result, Nick claims that he is "inclined to reserve all judgments," presenting himself to the reader as a fair and dispassionate arbiter of character, and thus, a reliable narrator.   The problem is that Nick immediately reveals himself as anything but reliable, as he then launches into a discussion of how pe...
Post a Comment
Read more

How did the United States become an imperial power?

"Imperial power" is a bit of a vague label. It tends to mean several things at once, so let's unpack it. In the sense of "this country was built on conquest by force," the "imperial power" part of America actually predates the United States proper. The territories that would become the United States were imperial colonies, established by the great European empires of the 17th and 18th centuries. Much of the US Constitution and American governance generally goes back to England, history's largest and most successful imperial power, but vital aspects of American culture come from other imperial powers, such as France and Spain. Much of American culture comes from sources other than the old empires, but they were key influences on what the United States became. In the sense of "this country treats conquest by force as a fundamental component of its culture, economy and politics," the United States has always been an imperial power. Even earl...
Post a Comment
Read more

How and why does James Gatz become Jay Gatsby? Describe the young Gatsby/Gatz.

James Gatz, a poor Midwestern boy of probable Jewish lineage, becomes Jay Gatsby, a presumed WASP and wealthy socialite, when he moves to New York City and acquires his fortune. It is wealth that has allowed Gatz to transform himself into Gatsby. However, those who know his background (e.g., Daisy and Tom Buchanan) never allow him to forget that he is nouveau riche -- that is, an upstart who has just recently made his fortune,... James Gatz, a poor Midwestern boy of probable Jewish lineage, becomes Jay Gatsby, a presumed WASP and wealthy socialite, when he moves to New York City and acquires his fortune. It is wealth that has allowed Gatz to transform himself into Gatsby. However, those who know his background (e.g., Daisy and Tom Buchanan) never allow him to forget that he is nouveau riche -- that is, an upstart who has just recently made his fortune, whereas they arose from well-to-do families. Gatz became Gatsby through determination and discipline. At the end of the novel, the narr...
Post a Comment
Read more